Please Read

If you'd like an account, please email accounts at this domain name  to ask for one. Include your email address and an explanation of why you want an account.

this is just a formality, to weed out spammers.

User login

PostHeaderIconSFWA Does Not Speak For Me

Douglas Preston is circulating a letter regarding the Amazon-Hachette dispute. In this letter, Preston finds Amazon alone guilty of multiple sins against Hachette authors. He encourages readers to email Jeff Bezos about the matter.

The dispute has exposed a big faultline in publishing, between those authors traditionally published by the Big Five (who have spared no words defending Hachette) and independent and self-published authors (who have been equally vociferous in defense of Amazon).

Myself, I've kept quiet about this kerfluffle because I didn't have a dog in this fight. I'm an independent author (without connection to any of the Big Five publishers.) I do make the lion's share of my sales through Amazon, so there's that.

Today, though, my professional society -- The Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America (SFWA) -- threw my dog into the fight. The President and Board of SFWA officially endorsed Preston's letter. They did so without discussion among the membership or, as near as I can tell, any attempt to determine the wishes of the members.

Yes, taking sides in a trade dispute is a boneheaded move. But it's worse: after years of prevarication, the lumbering SFWA dinosaur is stirring itself to address the question of whether to allow self-published writers who meet certain income requirements to join as professional authors. (Now and previously, only those published by a limited number of SFWA-approved markets could join.)

Just last week SFWA made its first public statement on the matter, asking members to share their opinions on allowing some self-published authors to apply for membership. A vote of the SFWA membership is promised suggested by November 2014.

For years, SFWA has been castigated in the self-publishing community, particularly by authors who support themselves and their families entirely on income from their self-publishing efforts, yet are unable to join an organization of professional writers. The public acknowledgment that SFWA was considering a change helped to smooth some feathers.

So what does SFWA do? It publicly and officially takes the side of traditional publishing, thereby signaling to independent and self-published writers that SFWA doesn't understand or care to understand their concerns. it's about as clear a message of "You don't belong and aren't welcome" as I've ever seen.

I know many hardworking members of SFWA who stood ready to resign if the vote goes against allowing self-published writers to join -- several of them have already said that this endorsement is the last straw.

I don't think I've ready to take that step -- the "resign from SFWA in moral indignation" phase of my career came and went decades ago. But I did want to make it absolutely clear that in this matter, SFWA does not speak for me.

Have you read?
The Book That Predicted Google Glass
The final battle of the Empress
Clone paranormal geniuses against the galactic empire
Two Tales of the Scattered Worlds
Visit a world in which scent and taste are as important as vision and hearing
Opening a new chapter in the Scattered Worlds Mosaic
How would intelligent, long-lived trees judge the Human race?
Classic gay teenage romance
The Fey vs the Galactic Empire
A Datebook Like No Other
Carmen Miranda's Ghost is Haunting Space Station Three
Lucky's Life is Turning Around
An anthology in celebration of queer speculative fiction.
An anthology celebrating queer speculative fiction.
The PsiScouts: X-Men meet Buck Rogers
collection of sf & fantasy stories, essay, and poetry by Maryland-area writers
A Scattered Worlds Omnibus
a Scattered Worlds omnibus
Psi-gifted teens tackle theocracy & a threat to history itself
A collection of sf/fantasy diversions